Prime Minister Accuses Caribbean Court of Justice of Slandering Barbados’ Judicial System

Prime Minister Freundel Stuart says Barbados is being unnecessarily slandered by the Caribbean Court of Justice.


BRIDGETOWN, Barbados, Wednesday December 6, 2017 – Prime Minister Freundel Stuart says Barbados’ judicial system has been “unnecessarily slandered” by the Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ).

The island’s final appellate court, which is based in Trinidad, has on three occasions bashed the Barbados courts for the time they take to hear and conclude cases, at one point saying that the long delays were deplorable.

Yesterday, for the first time, Stuart publicly addressed the matter in the House of Assembly, charging that such judicial delays were not peculiar to Barbados but were an issue throughout the Caribbean. However, he said while this was the case, the Privy Council, which was the appellate court for all the other Caribbean jurisdictions, handled the issue of delays in a more diplomatic fashion.

“I do not get too overwhelmed with what the CCJ says. We do not rejoice that there are delays in the system – there are delays and we have to deal with them – but I sometimes think that Barbados is being unnecessarily slandered by some of the reports I see,” he told Parliament.

He reminded that only four CARICOM countries – Barbados, Guyana, Belize and Dominica – had signed onto the CCJ’s appellate jurisdiction, while all the others continued to go to UK’s Privy Council.

“When you read decisions coming out of the Privy Council, evidence of horrible delays are uncovered in CARICOM countries that have not signed onto the CCJ. [It] handles that issue of delays much less salaciously than it seems to be the case of how it is handled in the Caribbean.

“These things are dealt with in one sentence, two at most, without any administering of rebuke or any holding up to ridicule . . . .”

Stuart, a Queen’s Counsel, explained that delays were a “serious problem” for all countries.

“But it is not going to function more efficiently if whenever there is evidence that there was delay, the country is held up to ridicule and the impression is given that we are not working and that is not right!” he maintained.

The Prime Minister said while he was speaking on the matter for the first time in Parliament, he had made his concerns known elsewhere.

“I am not here saying that the issue is one in respect of which we can rest on our laurels. I am just saying it is a regional problem and those countries that have signed onto the CCJ come under the CCJ spotlight. Those that have not signed onto the CCJ come under the spotlight of the Privy Council, which handles them fundamentally different than how they are handled in the region.” (Barbados Nation)

Click here to receive news via email from Caribbean360. (View sample)